On Eco-Friendly Contact Lenses: ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day vs Biotrue ONEday

Acuvue Oasys 1-Day vs Biotrue ONEday

In an era marked by a growing emphasis on environmental responsibility, contact lens wearers are given an important choice: opt for biodegradable lenses or embrace recyclable alternatives. This eco-conscious decision-making process is reshaping the eye care landscape, with several brands leading the way in sustainable solutions. Two of these brands are ACUVUE and Biotrue. 

In this green eye care showdown, we’ll compare ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day and Biotrue ONEday contact lenses, highlighting their eco-friendly features, performance, and overall impact on the environment to help you make an eco-conscious decision moving forward. Please read on.

ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day vs Biotrue ONEday: A Detailed Comparison

In the realm of daily disposable contact lenses, ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day and Biotrue ONEday stand out as top contenders, each offering unique features and benefits. As wearers prioritize comfort, clarity, and sustainability, the choice between these two brands becomes increasingly significant. 

The sections below provide a detailed comparison between these two eco-friendly contact lens brands. 

FeatureAcuvue Oasys 1-DayBiotrue ONEday
Lens MaterialSilicone hydrogelNesofilcon A
Oxygen PermeabilityHighHigh
Water Content38%78%
UV ProtectionYesNo
Moisture TechnologyHydraclear PlusSurface Active Technology
PackagingPlasticBio-inspired materials
Available ParametersBase Curve: 8.5 mm, Diameter: 14.3 mmBase Curve: 8.6 mm, Diameter: 14.2 mm
Power Range: -12.00 to +8.00Power Range: -9.00 to +6.00

Eco-Friendly Features

  • ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day: While not classified as biodegradable, ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day lenses are recyclable. They can be returned to participating optometrists or recycling centers for proper disposal. ACUVUE’s innovative recycling program ensures that used contact lenses and packaging materials are processed responsibly, reducing waste and environmental impact.
  • Biotrue ONEday: Biotrue ONEday lenses take eco-friendliness to the next level with their biodegradable design. Made from bio-inspired materials, these lenses decompose naturally over time, minimizing environmental pollution and landfill waste. Biotrue’s commitment to sustainability extends to its manufacturing processes, ensuring that every aspect of production aligns with eco-conscious principles.

Material and Design

  • ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day: Constructed with Senofilcon A, a silicone hydrogel material known for its high oxygen permeability and moisture retention properties. ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day lenses feature Hydraclear Plus technology, providing all-day comfort and clarity for wearers with dry or sensitive eyes. The lenses offer exceptional breathability and UV protection, promoting eye health and comfort.
  • Biotrue ONEday: Engineered with Nesofilcon A, another silicone hydrogel material that mimics the natural properties of the eye’s tear film. Biotrue ONEday lenses maintain moisture and hydration throughout the day, reducing dryness and irritation. The bio-inspired design ensures optimal oxygen transmission to the cornea, supporting long-term eye health and comfort.

Comfort and Moisture

Eco-friendly contact lenses
  • ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day: Renowned for their exceptional comfort, ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day lenses provide all-day hydration and moisture retention. The Hydraclear Plus technology creates a wettable surface that resists protein buildup and maintains clarity, even in challenging environments. Wearers can enjoy extended wear without sacrificing comfort or visual acuity.
  • Biotrue ONEday: Designed to mimic the eye’s natural moisture level, Biotrue ONEday lenses offer sustained hydration and comfort from morning to night. The lenses maintain moisture throughout the day, preventing dryness and discomfort associated with prolonged wear. Biotrue’s bio-inspired design ensures a comfortable fit and optimal visual performance for wearers of all ages.

Breathability and Oxygen Transmission

  • ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day: With a high Dk/t value, ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day lenses provide superior oxygen transmission to the cornea, promoting eye health and reducing the risk of hypoxia. The silicone hydrogel material allows ample oxygen flow, even during extended wear, ensuring optimal comfort and safety for wearers.
  • Biotrue ONEday: Equipped with a similar Dk/t value, Biotrue ONEday lenses offer optimal oxygen permeability, supporting healthy corneal metabolism and minimizing the risk of hypoxic complications. The silicone hydrogel material allows for extended wear without compromising eye health or comfort, making them suitable for daily use.

UV Protection

  • ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day: Featuring Class 1 UV protection, ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day lenses block 90% of UVA and 99% of UVB rays, providing an added layer of defense against harmful ultraviolet radiation. This UV-blocking technology helps reduce the risk of UV-related eye conditions, such as cataracts and macular degeneration, promoting long-term eye health and safety.
  • Biotrue ONEday: While Biotrue ONEday lenses do not offer UV protection, wearing sunglasses or UV-blocking eyewear outdoors is recommended to shield the eyes from harmful UV rays. Biotrue’s focus on sustainability extends to its packaging materials, which are made from recycled and biodegradable materials, further reducing environmental impact.

Convenience and Replacement Schedule

  • ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day: Available in a convenient daily disposable format, ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day lenses eliminate the need for cleaning and storage, making them ideal for users seeking hassle-free maintenance. Simply discard your lenses at the end of each day and start fresh with a new pair the next morning. ACUVUE’s commitment to eco-friendliness extends to its recycling program, ensuring responsible disposal of used lenses and packaging materials.
  • Biotrue ONEday: Designed for daily disposable use, Biotrue ONEday lenses offer the same convenience and ease of use as ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day lenses. Simply discard your lenses at the end of each day and enjoy fresh, clean lenses every morning. Biotrue’s biodegradable design further enhances its eco-friendly appeal, providing environmentally-conscious wearers with a sustainable choice for daily eye care.

Biodegradable vs. Recyclable Contact Lenses: Which Is Better?

To help you figure out which type of contact lenses is better for the environment, the table below outlines the key differences between biodegradable and recyclable contact lenses in terms of several aspects. 

AspectBiodegradable Contact LensesRecyclable Contact Lenses
Material CompositionMade from materials that naturally break down and decomposeMade from materials designed for collection, processing, and recycling
DisposalRequires specific conditions for optimal decompositionNeeds to be collected separately and sent to designated recycling centers
Environmental ImpactAims to reduce non-degradable waste in landfillsAims to create a closed-loop system, reducing the need for new raw materials
ExampleBiotrue ONEday by Bausch + LombACUVUE Oasys 1-Day
Conditions for DecompositionDecomposes naturallyRequires collection and processing in recycling facilities
User InvolvementBreaks down without specific user actionsUsers actively participate in recycling programs
Infrastructure RequirementsMay require specific disposal conditionsRequires established collection and recycling infrastructures

Key Takeaway: Toward a Greener Vision

Promoting eco-friendly contact lenses for a greener future.

The journey toward sustainable eye care extends beyond lens materials. It focuses on educating users about disposal methods and fostering collaboration within the eye care industry. Brands, optometrists, and wearers must work hand in hand to facilitate a smooth transition toward environmentally friendly options. This involves promoting recycling initiatives, ensuring accessibility to sustainable choices, and cultivating a collective commitment to minimizing the environmental impact of contact lenses.

In conclusion, both ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day and Biotrue ONEday offer superior comfort, clarity, and sustainability for environmentally conscious contact lens wearers. Your choice between the two will depend on your individual preferences, lifestyle, and commitment to eco-friendly practices. Whether you opt for the recyclable design of ACUVUE Oasys 1-Day or the biodegradable features of Biotrue ONEday, rest assured that you’re investing in premium eye care while minimizing your environmental impact.